The true, tangled history of the Aran sweater
True story-ish?
Although this story may not be true, it is interesting to look into how myths can become more widespread than facts. In this article, we will be looking deeper into the origins of the famous Aran Knitwear of Ireland.
The myth
It is commonly believed that in the Aran Islands of Ireland, every family has a different knitting pattern within their Aran Knits. This meant that if a fisherman drowned and washed up on shore, they would be identifiable from the pattern of knitting on their clothing. However, this story is almost completely untrue.
True story (for real)
In actuality, Aran Knitwear is a much more modern creation. The earliest examples of Aran knitwear are seen in the early 20th century and evolved from simpler navy ‘gansey’ sweaters worn by fishermen throughout the British Isles. However, from the 1890s, the Congested Districts Board (a government body aimed at reducing poverty on the islands) encouraged local people to knit Aran sweaters as a small-scale industry. As a result, the complex knit patterns now known as Aran knitwear developed.
Origins of drowned fishermen
Most textile historians agree that this particular myth originates from a play written by J.M. Synge in 1904. Within the play, called Riders to the Sea, a woman identifies her son's body from the pattern in his knitting. However, in this instance, it is not the pattern in his sweater that allows her to do this, but a dropped stitch in his hand-knitted socks. Over time, however, this detail was exaggerated and expanded. As a result of this, in the 20th century, the myth became widespread that every family had a unique pattern within their knitting. Tourism boards and knitting marketers in mid-century were very happy to continue this myth, as it gave the impression that every Aran Knit sold by them carried hundreds of years of tradition and gravitas.
Why it still stands
Despite the corrected information, Aran Knits are no less impressive. They have intricate combinations of cable, honeycomb and diamond patterns, created through incredible ingenuity and effort. Although the patterns' meanings are not used to identify people as the myth suggests, those who knit them do attribute meanings to them. In popular folklore -and among many modern knitters- the cables represent safety and returning from fishing, the honeycomb represents the hard-working nature of bees, and the diamonds represent the small plots of land in the islands. However, they were never used as an actual means of identification.
Overall
This is a great example of why folklore does not need to be historically accurate to still be valuable. As long as the story is honest and it is clearly separated from historical information, then there is no issue. The True story of the Aran Knit is incredibly compelling. Despite having come from a place of poverty, it displays incredible skill in knitting and was a whole small-scale industry created by women on just a few islands off the coast of Ireland. Therefore, even without the added drama of the folk tale, it is incredibly interesting.
Stay warm,
Loris